Transgender Law Center Sign up! DONATE
  • #13482 (no title)
  • #morethanmarriage
    • Become a #morethanmarriage organizational partner
    • FAITH
  • 10th Anniversary
  • 1121
  • 2017 Anti-Trans Legislation
  • 9th Anniversary Celebration – 2011
  • About
    • Careers, Internships and Volunteer Opportunities
      • Communications Director, CA Public Education Campaign
      • Community Engagement Director, CA Public Education Campaign
      • Contract Helpline Attorney – SFO/Oakland
      • Coordinator: Trans Advocacy Network & Transgender Law Center
      • Development Manager
      • Development Manager (Associate)
      • Director of Development
      • Law Clerk / Legal Internship Positions
      • Legal Assistant
      • Legal Services Project Manager or Attorney
      • Now Hiring Program Manager
      • Now Hiring: Program Manager
      • Now Hiring: Staff Attorney
      • Project HEALTH Program Manager
      • Southern Regional Director
      • Staff Attorney
      • Staff Attorney, Detention Project
      • Temporary Operations Associate
      • TIDE Pro Bono Coordinator
      • TLC@SONG Summer Legal Internship
      • Transgender Law Center Hires Deputy Director & Staff Attorney
      • TRANSGENDER LAW CENTER IS SEEKING LAW CLERKS!
      • Transgender Leadership Summit Event Planner
      • Volunteer, Detention Project
    • Media/Press
      • Infographics
    • Meet our Team
      • #977 (no title)
      • Ace Portis
      • Anand Kalra
      • Asa King
      • Billy Chen
      • Cecilia Chung
      • Dale Melchert
      • Daniel Faessler
      • Eden Jequinto
      • Elliott Fukui
      • Flor Bermudez
      • Ian Anderson
      • Ilona Turner
      • Isa Noyola
      • Isabella Rodriguez
      • Jack Dunn
      • Jennifer Orthwein
      • Jill Marcellus
      • Kara Desiderio
      • Khatchadour Khatchadourian
      • Kris Hayashi
      • Kristina Wertz
      • Lynly Egyes
      • Maceo Persson
      • Michelle Garcia
      • Mickyel “Micky” Bradford
      • Nancy Otto
      • Nomi Gomes
      • Ola Osaze
      • Olga Tomchin
      • Paige Kruza
      • Raquel Willis
      • Riley Hewko
      • Roman Venalonzo
      • Shawn Meerkamper
      • Shelby Chestnut
      • Sophia Kass
      • Tracy Garza
      • Wazi Maret
    • Support Our Work
    • Values
  • Are you #ACApositive? Join the campaign!
  • Arizona
  • Ask Danny: ID Doc Changes
  • BLOG
  • Brunchy Bon Voyage
  • Coming Out
  • Coming soon to a neighborhood near you…
  • Contact Us
  • Donate
  • Donate
  • Donate
    • Changemaker’s Society
    • Transgender Justice Council
  • eeoc
  • Employment Documents
  • Español
    • Blogs en español
    • Programas de TLC
    • Recursos y publicaciones
    • Sobre Nosotros
  • Events
    • SPARK! Photos
  • Events
    • Transgender Leadership Summit
      • Leadership Summit Logistics
      • Schedule
      • Workshops
    • Transgender Leadership Summit: Call for Workshop and Caucus Proposals
  • Fight Injustice with your Gift Today!
  • Free Marichuy: Org Letter Sign-On
  • Give
  • Give OUT Day 2015
  • Give OUT Day 2016
  • Giving As Resistance
  • Giving As Resistance
  • Gov. Pence: change the law targeting trans immigrants!
  • Healthy People Healthy Communities
  • HOME
  • Join the movement. Stay Up-To-Date!
  • Join TLC’s Community Resistance Network
  • Leading Change
  • Legal Fellow
  • Legal Resistance Network
  • Map of State Legislation
  • marriage
  • Masen & Bear: End of Year Message
  • Meet the families: Gavin Grimm amicus brief
  • My Authentic Life
    • How To Share Your Story
    • Photos & Quotes
    • Submit Your Story
  • Name That Schwag!
  • National Equality Map
  • Norsworthy v. Beard
  • Opportunities For Corporate Engagement
  • Our Legal and Policy Work
    • Employment Legal & Policy Work
    • Family Law Legal & Policy Work
    • Health Legal & Policy Work
    • Housing Legal & Policy Work
    • Identity Documents Legal & Policy Work
      • Doe v. Holcomb (formerly Doe v. Pence)
      • Mott v. Kansas Dept. of Health and Environment
    • Immigration Legal & Policy Work
      • Roxsana Hernandez
    • Prisons and Policing Legal & Policy Work
    • Public Accommodations Legal & Policy Work
    • Trans and gender nonconforming people speak out: stories of discrimination
    • Youth Legal & Policy Work
      • Prescott v. Rady Children’s Hospital-San Diego
      • Whitaker v. Kenosha Unified School District
  • Petitions
  • Philanthropic Development Volunteers
  • Positively Trans (Private)
  • Programs
    • Black LGBTQIA+ Migrant Project (BLMP)
      • BLMP Steering Committee
      • Get involved with BLMP
    • Detention Project
    • Legal Information Helpline
    • National Training Institute
    • Positively Trans (T+)
      • Positively Trans National Advisory Board
      • Positively Trans Needs Assessment: Reports 1-3
      • Positively Trans Report 2: Some Kind of Strength
      • Positively Trans Report 3: See Us As People
      • Positively Trans Video Library
    • TLC@SONG
    • Trans Immigrant Defense Effort (TIDE)
    • Transforming Institutions
    • TRUTH: trans and gender non-conforming youth storytelling movement
  • Quine v. Beard
  • Reception for TLC’s New Legal Director
  • Reports & Publications
    • 2006 Annual Report
    • 2007 Annual Report
    • 2008 Annual Report
    • 2011 Annual Report
    • Introducing Our Interactive Annual Report Magazine!
    • The State of Transgender California
  • Request Legal Information
  • Resources
    • A Practitioner’s Guide to California Transgender Law: A Reference Guide for California Lawyers and Advocates
    • Action Center
      • Communities Against Hate
      • Contact Your Legislators
    • Conozca sus derechos: Presentando una queja ante la EEOC por discriminación en el empleo
    • Employment Resources
      • EEOC Webinar: Transgender Rights in the Workplace
      • Good Jobs NOW!
      • Know Your Rights: Filing an Employment Discrimination Complaint with the EEOC
      • Know Your Rights: Title VII and EEOC Rulings Protect Transgender Employees
      • Know Your Rights: Transgender People at Work
      • Lusardi EEOC Decision FAQ
      • Macy EEOC Ruling F.A.Q.
      • Model Employer Policy
      • Tips for Lawyers Working with Transgender Clients and Coworkers
      • Tips for Working with Transgender Coworkers
      • TLC ENDA Testimony to the US Senate 2012
      • Transgender Employees and Tenants in California: Rights and Responsibilities
    • Family Law Resources
      • Beattie v. Beattie Decision
      • Conover v. Conover Amicus Brief
      • Miller v. Angel Amicus Brief
      • Transgender Family Law
      • Transgender Family Law 101
      • Transgender Family Law Facts
      • Transitioning Your Services: Serving Transgender Victims of Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Stalking
    • Health Resources
      • 10 Tips for Working with Transgender Patients
      • Affordable Care Act Fact Sheet
      • Health Care Reform Q & A: Transgender Californians
      • How to Appeal Your Health Care Denial
      • How To Start A Transgender Clinic
      • La Salud De Personas Transgénero y La Ley (Health Care Fact Sheet in Spanish)
      • MediCal Fact Sheet
      • Negotiating for Inclusive Health Insurance Coverage
      • Organizing for Transgender Health Care
      • Soy una persona transgénero y vivo en California. ¿Que necesito saber sobre la reforma de cuidado médico?
      • States with Non-Discrimination Health Insurance Bulletins
      • Transgender Health and the Law: Identifying and Fighting Health Care Discrimination
    • Housing Resources
      • AB 196: What it means for you
      • United States of America v. George Toone and In Toone Services, LLC
    • Identity Documents Resources
      • CA ID Change Forms
        • ID Please Online
      • Changing Legal Identity Documents in California
      • Changing Your Legal Identification in California
      • Fact Sheet: California’s Gender Recognition Act (SB 179)
      • FAQ: The Vital Statistics Modernization Act
      • ID Documents Fact Sheet
      • ID Please CA: Full Guide to Changing California and Federal Identity Documents
      • ID Please: Quick Guide to Changing Federal Identity Documents
      • Real ID Act
      • State-by-State Overview: Changing Gender Markers on Birth Certificates
      • Trans Legal Clinic Calendar
    • Immigration Resources
      • Asylum Fact Sheet
      • Asylum Fact Sheet
      • Credible Fear Interviews: What you Need to Know as a TGNC Immigrant
      • ICE Memorandum: Orientación Respecto Al Cuidado Detenidos Transgénero
      • ICE Raids: Know Your Rights as a TGNC Immigrant
      • Immigration Law & Transgender People (English)
      • La Solicitud de Asilo Basada en la Persecucion por Identidad dé Genero
      • Las Entrevistas de Miedo Creíbles: Que Necesitas Saber Si Eres es Un Inmigrante TGNC
      • Las leyes migratorias y las personas transgénero
      • Redadas de ICE: Que Necesitas Saber Si Eres es Un Inmigrante Transgénero o género-no-conforme (TGNC)
      • Report on Human Rights Conditions of Transgender Women in Mexico
      • S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) Policy Memorandum
    • Know Your Rights
      • FAQ: The Gender Nondiscrimination Act
    • Miller v. Angel Decision
    • Policy Desk
    • Prisons and Policing Resources
      • Advocating for Yourself While in Custody in California
      • Policy Recommendations Regarding LGBT People in California Prisons
      • Safety Inside
    • Public Accommodations Resources
      • Doe v. Regional School Unit 26
      • Peeing in Peace
    • Tools for Transgender and Gender-Nonconforming People to Address Discrimination
    • Youth Resources
      • Amicus Brief, California Education Committee, LLC v. Jack O’Connell
      • Beyond the Binary
      • California Education Committee, LLC v. Jack O’Connell, Decision
      • Quick Steps You Can Take to Move Your School Beyond the Binary
      • TLC Comments to US Commission on Civil Rights about Peer Violence in Schools
  • Safe Schools
  • School Success and Opportunity Act (AB 1266)
  • sfpride
  • Sign up for emails from Transgender Law Center!
  • Spark Mockup
  • SPARK!
    • JOIN THE SPARK! HOST COMMITTEE
    • SPARK! – Your Sponsorship Makes our Work Possible
    • SPARK! 2013 Host Committee & Sponsorship
    • SPARK! 2014 Authentic Life Award Nomination Form
    • SPARK! 2014 Vanguard Award Nomination Form
    • SPARK! Awardees
    • SPARK! Claire Skiffington Vanguard Award Nomination Form
    • SPARK! Host Committee 2014
    • SPARK! Igniter
  • SPARK! 2012
  • SPARK! 2013
  • SPARK! 2013
  • SPARK! 2014
  • SPARK! 2015
  • SPARK! 2016
  • SPARK! 2017
  • suicide prevention
  • Support Our Youth
  • Support Our Youth
  • Take Action: North Carolina’s HB2
  • Thank You!
  • Trans Advocacy Day – 2011
  • Trans Leadership Summit – 2011
  • Trans Youth Deserve Better
  • Transform Tech
  • Transform Tech 2017
  • Transgender Day of Remembrance
  • Transgender Justice Council
  • Transgender Leadership Summit
  • Transgender Leadership Summit
  • Transgender Legal Services Project
  • Updates
    • TLC in the Press
  • Volunteer with TLC
  • Vote #TransLawCenter for #SFPride2015 and #Bestie
  • 2009 Annual Report
  • 2010 Annual Report
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
Transgender Law Center
  • ABOUT
    • Contact Us
    • Support Our Work
    • Mission and Values
    • For Media/Press
    • Staff and Board
    • Careers/Internships
  • PROGRAMS
    • Black LGBTQIA+ Migrant Project (BLMP)
    • Detention Project
    • National Training Institute
    • Positively Trans (T+)
    • TLC@SONG
    • Trans Immigrant Defense Effort (TIDE)
    • TRUTH
    • Volunteer Programs
  • CASES & POLICY
    • Employment
    • Family Law
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Identity Documents
    • Immigration
    • Prisons and Policing
    • Public Accommodations
    • Youth
  • RESOURCES
    • Employment
    • Family Law
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Identity Documents
    • Immigration
    • Prisons and Policing
    • Public Accommodations
    • Youth
    • See All Publications and Resources
  • BLOG
  • GET LEGAL INFO
  • ESPAÑOL
    • Sobre Nosotros
    • Programas de TLC
    • Necesita Ayuda Legal?
    • Recursos y publicaciones
    • Blogs en español
  • GIVE
Home» Featured » Journalists: Commit to Fair and Accurate Coverage of Transgender People, including Pvt. Chelsea Manning

Journalists: Commit to Fair and Accurate Coverage of Transgender People, including Pvt. Chelsea Manning

September 4, 2013 | by admin | Featured, Identification, Movement Building | No Comments

pronounsmediaTransgender Law Center has signed on to a letter calling on journalists to learn best practices for reporting on transgender issues.

“The past few weeks have been a teachable moment for both the public and the media, and we hope the many well-meaning journalists continue to grow and learn about transgender people so that their lives can be respectfully and accurately reported on. Ultimately, fair and accurate reporting on transgender people will help reduce the inexcusable, extraordinarily high levels of violence and discrimination the community faces.” – Mark D. Snyder, Transgender Law Center Communications Manager

Journalists: Commit to Fair and Accurate Coverage of Transgender People, including Pvt. Chelsea Manning

The media has a long and poor track record of reporting on transgender people, and the coverage surrounding Private Chelsea Manning has brought that lack of fair and accurate coverage into sharp focus. The coverage that we have seen thus far has relied on stereotypical images, contrived confusion over names and pronouns, and an obsession with surgery. Examples include:

  • USA Today displaying a graphic that outlines several of the surgeries transgender women may elect to undergo, overemphasizing and sensationalizing the role of surgeries in the life of a transgender person.  A transgender identity is not determined by medical procedures.
  • The New York Times, Washington Post, CNN, NPR, NBC, Fox News, Reuters, and a host of other outlets wrote articles that outlined the “struggles” that media outlets faced in referring to Private Manning as Chelsea or choosing a pronoun. The Washington Post, Fox News, and CNN still refuse to honor Private Manning’s preferred name and pronouns.
  • CNN’s Jake Tapper conducted an interview with a close friend of Manning, continually referring to Manning as Bradley, and also referring to his guest as a “gay man” when she is a transgender woman.

The media disrespected and insulted all transgender people by using phrases like “choose to be a girl,” and CNN panelist Richard Herman saying that Manning will “get good practice” as a woman in prison. Fox News offensively teased a broadcast segment on Private Manning by playing Aerosmith’s “Dude (Looks Like A Lady).”

Transgender people face tremendous levels of discrimination and violence. According to the National Coalition of Anti-Violence Programs(NCAVP), 53% of anti-LGBT homicide victims in 2012 were transgender women – most were transgender women of color. According to the report“Injustice at Every Turn”:

  • Transgender people experience unemployment at twice the rate of the general population, with rates for people of color up to four times the national unemployment rate.
  • 90% of transgender people report experiencing harassment, mistreatment or discrimination on the job.
  • 22% of respondents who have interacted with police reported harassment by police, with much higher rates reported by people of color.
  • Almost half of the respondents (46%) reported being uncomfortable seeking police assistance.
  • 41% of respondents reported attempting suicide, compared to 1.6% of the general population.

We, the undersigned organizations, call on journalists and media outlets to cover all transgender people with the dignity they deserve as human beings. Private Manning issued a public statement, read by her lawyer, that explicitly and unambiguously stated that she should be referred to as Chelsea and to use female pronouns. The Associated Press and theNew York Times have both announced that they will refer to Chelsea as she requested, and other media outlets should do the same.

The Associated Press Style Guide states that when referring to a transgender person, to “Use the pronoun preferred by the individuals.” GLAAD’s full Media Reference Guide on reporting on transgender people may be found here.

The following are commonly accepted guidelines for covering a transgender person:

  • Always use a transgender person’s preferred name.
  • Whenever possible, ask transgender people which pronoun they would like used.  
  • Do not put quotation marks around either a transgender person’s preferred name or the pronoun that reflects that person’s gender identity.
  • Avoid pronoun confusion when examining the stories and backgrounds of transgender people prior to their transition. In Private Manning’s case, she may simply be referred to as Private Manning.

Private Manning’s story presents an opportunity for the media to do a better job of telling the story of everyday transgender people who are simply trying to live their lives. The media has an opportunity – and the responsibility – to improve its reporting and accurately reflect the lives of transgender people.

Black Transmen & Black Transwomen

Capital City Alliance

Center for Lesbian and Gay Studies in Religion and Ministry

Center of Excellence for Transgender Health

DC Trans Coalition

Equality Louisiana

Family Equality Council

FORGE

Gay, Lesbian & Straight Education Network (GLSEN)

GAYa NUSANTARA

Gender Alliance of the South Sound

Gender Justice League

Gender Justice Nevada

 

Gender Rights Advocacy Association of New Jersey

GLAAD

HBTS Sweden

Human Rights Campaign

Humanist Institute for Co-operation with Developing Countries

Kansas Statewide Transgender Education Project

Louisiana Trans Advocates

Media Matters

Metropolitan Community ChurchTrans* and GNC Advisory Council

National Center for Transgender Equality

National Coalition of Anti-Violence Projects

National Gay and Lesbian Task Force

Rainbow Community Cares

SAGE (Services and Advocacy for GLBT Elders)

SPART*A

SunServe

Sylvia Rivera Law Project

Tennessee Transgender Political Coalition

The Gay & Lesbian Community Center of Southern Nevada

Trans Advocacy Network

Trans Media Watch

Trans Youth Equality Foundation

Trans*Action Florida

TransEpiscopal

Transfaith

Transgender Education Network of Texas

Transgender Equality Rights Initiatives

Transgender Individuals Living Their Truth

Transgender Law Center

Transgender Victoria

TransLutherans

TransOhio

TransYouth Family Allies

Truth Wins Out

United Church of Christ GenderFold Action Alliance

Transgender Law Center | p. 510-587-9696 | EIN (tax identification number): 05-0544006 | info@transgenderlawcenter.org

Sign up!